Wednesday, January 9, 2008
Good Intention, Wrong Person
I adore a good intention.
I love to watch other people do the "right thing" ...the "honorable thing" ....the " kind thing"....and like to think of myself as a person who would do anything, within my power, to help another human being.
But today, I find myself at odds with what was supposed to be a random act of kindness last night, that feels like a major f*** up today. The short of it~~ I was driving when I noticed a small truck that had slid off the road. It had been snowing all day, was slick out and the fact a truck was off the road wasn't exactly alarming, considering.......so I slowed down enough to notice a woman wandering around behind her truck. I pulled over to see if she needed help, a pretty much automatic reaction, right?
This woman hurried over to my vehicle, breathless, panicked, frantic and when I asked if I could do something she exclaimed a ride home would be perfect, she'll just grab her truck later. The truck looked pretty stuck, at a strangle angle, etc etc. A ride I could do, not a big detour off my course, and off we went. Random act of kindness in live action............
But this is where my feel good thoughts turned bad. For one, she was ranting and raving about extremely strange topics. She would say, "Thank You, Thank You, your 're my angel!" and then in the next breath says " Don't you just HATE woman, aren't woman just horrible ,<insert several colorful cuss words here> " and so on.....
....and the more she talked, the more my vehicle filled up with the stench of alcohol.
This is where I started to feel sick. I realized I was helping a drunk driver evade facing the consequences of driving while intoxicated.....gut sick about it.
I have a notion about drunk drivers. For one, I don't give a shit who you are, if you drink and drive, you deserve nothing less then a nice little jail cell to sober you up. No excuses, no exceptions, no mercy. In my world, there is no gray zone for drinking and driving. Not even the 'just a beer or two' slides past my no tolerance for drinking and driving ideals when it comes to this topic. So, imagine my dilemma to discover I was helping a drunk driver.
And yes, I asked, "So, how much have you had to drink tonight??"
To which she replied, laughing, slurring, " I'm sooo like fucking wasted, I just luvvvvv Whiskey!"
I did drop this woman off at her house.
Although, today I wish I would have turned around, taken her back to her truck, kicked her out my door, made a call, and then waited for the police to show up. I wish I had, but I didn't and today it hasn't settled very well with me. Not well at all.
In a world where actions and consequences reign supreme, I helped a woman avoid the pain of her choices........
Isn't that like most situations, where there's this constant collision of human to human in life, that it takes time... 5 minutes, or a day to create 10 extra possibilities we could have enacted. A better come back, a better action, a better reaction, a better sentence or choice. Today I've thought of 10 things I could have done that would have made my choices last night sit alittle more upright within myself.
For Jennae, the moronic woman in Boise Idaho, age 41, driving a black Toyota truck. Your truck was in the ditch off Broadway. You embarrass me, you and your choices. I regret helping you for one single second. I fear you will drink and drive again and maybe next time you'll harm an innocent........that makes me nauseous. You left your CD player faceplate from your truck on my dashboard. Although I remember where you live, I have no intentions of dropping it off out of kindness. Perhaps you'll feel 'alittle somethin' when you have to pay to replace it. Let's call it, a much cheaper consequence then the cost of a DUI, or killing someone...............
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

28 comments:
If it helps, you kept her from killing herself or others by wandering around in the road in the dark. Seriously, Rebecca. As dangerous as drunks are behind the wheel, they're equally dangerous once they get out of their cars and start stumbling around on the pavement.
So, soothe your guilt with the notion that you probably helped keep someone from losing control of their car after swerving to avoid a stupid, stumbling drunk in the road.
See? Bright side.
-Dan
http://thewisdomofadistractedmind.blogspot.com/
Oh Rebecca. You meant to do a good thing, it was a good thing to stop and try to help. Actually, though, in this day and age it's a little dangerous for a single person in a car to stop and offer help on a lonely road. Better yet, if you had a cell phone a call placed to 911 and report the incident. It gets the person help, but does not put you in danger my dear. My Joe stops all the time, if he sees someone stuck on the road..over the years he has helped dozens of people. He just tells everyone to "Pass it on". Even though he is in construction and can take care of himself I always hope that no one will attack him when he does this. Anyway thinking back, I've put myself out there a couple of times, I was walking my daughter home from school one day and there was a man beating the crap out of his dog - I lost it. This man backed up real fast with a screaming umbrella wielding lunatic charging at him. He actually left the dog, I wound up taking the dog home and finding a good home for it. But I was much younger then. Lol....love, Sandi
you did the right thing:) maybe you could go and give the cops a heads up on this lady if she was drunk she will be again and they could be on the look out for her. enjoy your weekend
Deb
Because this woman did not get arrested, does not change that you did a good thing. You helped a stranger out. Whether that stranger was drunk and should have been arrested is a completely separate issue than what you did being a good thing to do, period.
You also never know what is going to push someone to get help. I guarantee she woke up ashamed, terribly ashamed. Sometimes that shame is what pushes you to get help. In any event you are not responsible for her journey, just for yours. And you may be more likely to do or not do something the next time around that you're more comfortable with the next day. Stop beating yourself up.
And, it REALLY was SNOWING yesterday too! How could you know you were dealing with a drunk in this weather? I don't believe we've had snow like this in 10 years! I believe your intentions were good, and you were taken advantage of. I'm not so sure you could have done any different... (well, maybe, you could have dumped her ass once you learned it was the whiskey and not the snow that caused her to land in a ditch.) I'm sure you were totally caught off guard and already enroute to this fool's home. Your heart and soul were in the right place, it was her heart and soul that was lost.
http://boiseladie.blogspot.com/
I think people who drink and drive are despicable. Don't beat yourself up about it though. You didn't realize when you agreed to take her home that she was drunk. Sure you could have taken her back to her truck and left her there to face her own consequences, but you didn't. Next time given the same choice I think you will do better. That's all any of us can do . . . better if given the chance again. (((hugs)))
Marie
http://journals.aol.co.uk/mariealicejoan/MariesMuses/
ohh...I'm sorry to hear this. I'm kinda surprised you let her get inside your car at all. What was coming through my mind was: what if she's dangerous?
I'm glad you're ok and you're not hurt.
I probably would have called the police on the spot since cellphones are reliable to use and carry pretty much everywhere.
If you want to, and if it helps to lessen how you're feeling today, can you still call the police today and let him know where the truck is?
You're a kind and caring person. I can understand your random act of kindness. Glad to know there are still people like you.
Gem :-)
Aye, that is horrible, Rebecca.
Chalk it up to a lesson learned - you did a good deed, even if she was drunk, and you learned a valuable lesson in the process. Maybe she did too, since she lost her stereo, but somehow I doubt it. I don't think she'll feel guilt about the situation, though. Concentrate on the positive aspect. ~~Kath~~
Yes, that's a thought provoking hand that I too would regret rendering. Drunks don't appeal to me in any regard or environment.
Oh well. It's all in the mind of the beholder. Some people would perceive it as a good thing. -- For instance, I know some about a woman with a remarkably selective conscience and zero intestinal fortitude who perpetually furthers a male that would largely be held as horrendous by most if they accurately discerned (or simply acknowledged) how indifferent, unbalanced, and detrimental to others he is. Yet, she apparently deeply sweats her lesser acts.
Could it be that actions and consequences don't reign as supreme as you imagine? Not likely. I'm way too familiar with karma.
Oh well, again ... if I awakened tomorrow and everyone thought like me, I'd kill myself out of sheer lack of variety.
Don't let it get you too down, Rebecca. There's bigger things to be concerned of.
~Brian
It sucks to be put in that kind of situation. YOu did a kind deed to a stranger but instead of getting that warm feeling of having helped someone you got the reverse. Shame on her not you. That was still a good deed and hopefully this woman changes her ways and stops driving drunk. Julie
Right thing it might not be, but honorable it was.
How many times did I do something in the name of good intention, then either regretted it or got into a mess because of it? Countless times, my friend. I used to be a social worker and I made many booboos in the name of good intention. I had the same reaction as you did in this entry. First, I got mad with myself, then I got mad at the people who took advantage of me. That is why I am pursuing a new line of work. I am tired of feeling like a big sucker.
Hugs to you, my big hearted noble friend.
Dee
Rebecca,
I have followed you long enought to understand your feelings. I agree, no shade of gray. I still live with an alcholic and I really don't have any room in my life for him or his actions....but then we can't pick our relatives. You did the same thing I would have. It was the honorable thing and I am proud of you.
David
Rebecca,
Never second guess an act of kindness.
Your assumption that your act of kindness has allowed her to escape her justice cannot be quantified.
You came away wiser, and your senses will be on a higher alert should you be called into action again!
I much prefer hearing that she went off the road, than into another vehicle filled with a family.
Go ahead, flap your wings and shake this off...a new day awaits, waiting for your kindness and love!
Always, Marc :)
Aye, life is indeed complicated isn't it? I don't know how many times I've put myself in danger to help out another.....only to realize it may of indeed been for naught. At the end of the day you breathe and chalk it up for what it is. Maybe this act of kindness didn't turn out the way you had hoped, but the next may very well be the one to make a difference. We are humans, not psychics. I think what you did was honorable, what the woman did was not.
I would go ahead and go to the police and file a report on what you know and were the woman was living. Perhaps tell them you have her CD changer in your car and in light of events , wouldn't feel right going back there. If the police return it, or call her to come pick it up, just walking in to the police station or seeing a cop may be a wake up call for her. Nothing may come of it, but at the very least you will know you tried to right this condundrum. Alcoholics are a strange lot, it takes them a huge jolt to actually get the message. It goes back to the feeling we wish we could save the world, save all the blighted. We can only do so much, every little bit helps. You did what I would expect from you, a random kindness; And there you have it........no matter the outcome, the reasoning, the result that is what it was in it's entirety, a random act of kindness. (Hugs) Indigo
I would also go ahead and let the police know. You did a very nice thing by stopping to help someone who looked like she needed help. It wasn't until later that you realized she'd been drinking, so don't beat yourself up too much. I've made decision and then realized later that I probably should have done something differently, so I understand how you feel.
Lori
I think you did a good thing. The intentions were right. Yes, she avoided her consequences one more time, unbeknownst to you when you picked her up. But this is not the first time, she's probably rolled the dice 100's of times before. The problem is the choices that she has made. You should not ascribe her bad decision making to your act of kindness.
Love the faceplate being left behind. Maybe you should send her an anonymous note saying she can pick it up at 123 Main St [Replace with the address of a local AA meeting]
I have not read all of the comments, so I hope this is not repetitive. It may be possible that you can still do something to see that this woman gets consequences for her actions. My husband is a police officer who takes pride in his many drunk driving arrests. He is often sent to a scene like the one you describe in your post, described as an "abandoned vehicle." He looks up the registration of the driver, finds an address, and visits to make sure that all is well. Sometimes he comes across a driver like you describe, but often by the time he gets there, he can tell that drinking was involved, but it is too late to gather evidence that will hold up in court.
If the police did visit this woman, the testimony of a good samaritan like you might help them make their case against her. I'd make a phone call to the police to find out if any reports were made against this woman. You might be able to help.
(low, long whistle......) Wow, can't say I've ever been face with this situation. Knowing what I do of you, you'll be skeptical in the future and rightly so. You're doing all you can at this point to deal with the repercussions of being a good Samaritan for someone who created the quagmire you found her in. This very example is why so few of us are eager to jump in with assistance...so sad really that dishonesty has tainted the good nature we all possess.
Tammy
Your heart was in the right place. I'd have done the same thing. The only difference was that once I'd smelled the alcohol I'd have taken her back to her truck and called the police..or dropped her home then called them..the reason being that a drunk driver killed my father when I was 15. I'm glad you are the kind of person who cares enough to help. Too many people don't.
Barb- http://journals.aol.com/barbpinion/HEYLETSTALK
You did what seemed right at the time. I honestly don't know what I'd do, as I've not been faced with that. I do not condone drunk driving, either, of course. I kept my dad's car inaccessible (sp) to him more than once. I suspect that you could still contact the local police. Or, be out on the watch for her. I'm glad to hear she didn't hurt anyone last night.
Somehow... your alerts have not been working for me... and I stupidly have been thinking, well, now Rebecca Anne has just not been journaling! Ack! Here you are! Journaling!
Catching up now... Oh that awful woman... maybe she will learn... I hope so.
be well,
Dawn
http://journals.aol.com/princesssaurora/CarpeDiem/
Rebecca,
I honestly don't know what I would have done in your shoes... probably the exact same thing you did! Of course it would have occurred to me, as it did you, to take her back to her car - but what would have stopped me is flat-out fear. She was drunk, she was unethical... there is no telling how she would have reacted to you turning the car around. Not how things are supposed to go when you're lending a helping hand, is it? What a bummer.
(((((Rebecca)))) Nice to see you. Don't let it smart too much...you still did the right thing...you saved her from walking into the road...and whatever else may have come her way. ;) C.
Oh, have I been THERE. I just hope it doesn't break your spirit for doling out what I call TRUE charity. It sure can AFFECT your perspective. The other day on campus I chased down a girl who'd had 50 dollars in small bills fly out of her pocket in the wind? She hadn't even realized it? The guy next to me chased down the money...when she got back to us? She just grabbed the money out of his hand and stormed off without a thank you. (she probably ripped off somebody's tip jar) But I STILL, and I'm no Spirng Chicken, like to think she was the exception and probably related, at least by marriage, to that dumb drunk broad in Boise.
Oh, have I been THERE. I just hope it doesn't break your spirit for doling out what I call TRUE charity. It sure can AFFECT your perspective. The other day on campus I chased down a girl who'd had 50 dollars in small bills fly out of her pocket in the wind? She hadn't even realized it? The guy next to me chased down the money...when she got back to us? She just grabbed the money out of his hand and stormed off without a thank you. (she probably ripped off somebody's tip jar) But I STILL, and I'm no Spirng Chicken, like to think she was the exception and probably related, at least by marriage, to that dumb drunk broad in Boise.
Oh, have I been THERE. I just hope it doesn't break your spirit for doling out what I call TRUE charity. It sure can AFFECT your perspective. The other day on campus I chased down a girl who'd had 50 dollars in small bills fly out of her pocket in the wind? She hadn't even realized it? The guy next to me chased down the money...when she got back to us? She just grabbed the money out of his hand and stormed off without a thank you. (she probably ripped off somebody's tip jar) But I STILL, and I'm no Spirng Chicken, like to think she was the exception and probably related, at least by marriage, to that dumb drunk broad in Boise.
I would have dropped her off and then called the police. -Missy http://journals.aol.com/ma24179/MISSYZSTUFF
Post a Comment