I've looked at the top of my journal, I've glanced at the bottom, and studied the sides. I've checked the dusty corners and rattled the squeaky headlines/entries for clues that would explain the recent happenings in my journal. I can only go back to the first question I had in my mind. A simple question really.
A one word-er
~~~W H Y~~~~
WHY
or what motivates people
both currently and in the past
to feel the need to comment, email and generally rain on my parade by pointing out things or mistakes they don't like about or in my writing?
WHY
being the mystified question
in my mind
~
Now, I believe, and I could be wrong, that I've taken the mature position by addressing all concerns, complaints, and unneeded suggestions personally via the email system. To which I believe the majority of it was smoothed out nicely and I hope this entry doesn't crumble the progress that was already achieved with those specific people.
Howevery, evidently that direction isn't working, because I keep getting the same invasive, unsolicited sideswipes about design, not content. <Did a group get together and decide it's pick on Rebecca's writing techniques for a while or is it all coincidence of interesting timing??>
SOoooooo............heres the deal. An explanation of my journal writing. In depth, down and dirty.
This space is unedited, typically UN-thought, sporadic and a simple corridor for the stream of conscious thoughts I have running untamed through my mind. I sit down and I write, I don't use backspace nor the delete button. I do NOT go back and reread what I've written. I always resist the urge to look back over my shoulder at my writing here because I KNOW myself and I would instantly start to edit/delete myself, my words, my writing and my thoughts.
I do not care about any of the following on the pages of this journal, and yes, I realize that because of this, I may not shine my writing in the best light, but here goes...... Spelling, grammar, sentence length, word definition, correct placement of ,.?! :;" ' , nouns, adjectives, dialogue, sentences that make sense or don't, and I certainly don't use any type of journal format.
I would like to think that in this space, if I would like my words to go on and on like a Virginia Woolf sentence, and use 20 commas, and write 10 metaphors and (and put in parenthesis anything I feel like) before I take a breath and end it with a period, I can do that because why in the world would anyone care enough to point it out as an issue and actually suggest I change MY writing because it's difficult on them, instead of that person just accepting my writing is my space and keep their displeasure to themselves, it is that type of WHY that I cannot grasp..............breath now.................(I can even use 40 periods for emphasis if I should feel the need)
I'm not a confrontational person, so I already know I'm going to hate this entry the moment I post it. Then again, I'm also not a person that ever willingly, knowingly, and intentionally <how's that for some pretty adjectives?> sets out to hurts a person feelings or tosses jabs on a whim. So when people do it to me, or others, I'm always left mouth agape and scratching my mind for answers and reasons.
Even now I'm worried about the very people who have sideswiped me over the last year with negative emails, concerns, suggestions and comments about my writing. Thoughts like, "Will they be hurt that I did an entry like this?" or "Will I piss off someone by my blanket outcry for no more sideswipes." Specifically, because it really isn't one person, or one comment thats finally done me in. It's an accumulation of unwarranted smacks that has me finally calling out that the straw finally broke my back, the icing is dripping from my cake and my last button was finally pushed.
My writing here is not perfect. I have never claimed it was.
My writing here is not scripted. I have never claimed it was.
My writing here shows warts and scars and dents and dings because it's my free zone.
My writing here is what it is, anything that happens to flow from my mind to my fingers.
My writing here has no agenda, no flow, no direction and should be devoid of expectation, obligation and guidelines.
On the flip side, the writing on my book is painfully slow and I take great care in the perfection of each and every single little word. Then I place it in the hands of trusted individuals with red pens and ruthless critique practices to butcher it all over again. In that arena, I am ready for critique, I am ready for the red pen, I am ready to be ripped to shreds so I can put it all back together again.
I am not prepared for, nor do I desire, critique on these pages. I am perfectly capable of doing that myself should I choose to do so. I don't think it is necessary. I do not believe it is needed. I have never asked for it and I shouldn't have to worry about it. What irritates me the most about this entry is the fact that I've received far more praise and encouragement from the people who have passed by then the negatives. I shouldn't even give these sideswipes a second thought, but like a burr stuck in my sock I need to eradicate it somehow.
I have been gone from home, life, and online journals for a long time. I've traveled far and wide for the last 8 months and hibernation is calling my name. I've had many new visitors I need to welcome and in turn visit their journals and I look forward to that. I've neglected my correspondence and visiting the journals of old friends, and I assure you I'll be back to my comment spamming very soon.
All I ask is when a person visits my personal journal, they take it for what it is. Nothing but words from a little lady sitting in her office in Idaho. When the desire plops itself in my writing lap I would like the freedom and clear mind of not worrying about if my sentences are perfect, without flaw and ready for publication.
This entry is to the point and if I offend anyone I apologize. I wrote an entry along these same lines, only nicer and more passive over a year ago, perhaps a refresher is due.........Concrete
It should be quite clear now, my purpose, or nonpurpose of this journal.
I write the good, the bad and the ugly and I'm fine with it~~
It's all Good

22 comments:
Rebecca.....it's nice to "see" you back and writing in your journal! I did a little happy dance when I saw you in my alerts. I've missed you. For me, reading your journal entries are very thought provoking. It's not what's written or how it's written that should matter. It's words......freely flowing and straight from your mind and heart. Again...it's great to "see" you back.
Hugs,
Gina
http://journals.aol.com/motoxmom72/j-land-convention/
http://journals.aol.com/motoxamom72/GinasWeigtLossJourney
Your color scheme sucks! And the pictures are wack.
You know I'm kidding. I don't know. No one's ever critiqued what I write, or how I make my journal (the blogger or the old one) look. It's your journal, write how you want.
Though when you wrote like me, I was flattered.
I get some people that tell me I spelled something wrong in my journal for the most part I think they are joking..but..I agree with you. This is a place I started to get my thoughts and feelings out..not to become some jounalist..or i would be sitting behind a desk getting paid to Blog...LOL..I love your journal the way it is..I think it is the fact that you got an award last year and they are getting ready for awards so maybe they just are trying to make their journal look better..who knows...at any rate..rock on sister!!! LOL..By the way>>>>I love the great new pic of yourself..very pretty you are!! hope all is well with you and your daughter...I think of you both often and keep you in my prayers and thoughts! Hugs,TerryAnn
love your journal just the way it is and wouldn't dare tell some one how or what to do with their own blog.. so I know your not talking about me lol
My only bla is that you dont write more often.. we miss you.. but I am in no place to complain since I am often MIA.
(((((HUGS)))))
Much Love,
Mary
hehehe, you gotta admit those critics are persistant little buggers. Hey, um, I guess I never thought of reading others journals the same as I do a published novel. Not like you owe anyone anything here. After all, are you making the big bucks with these words? Are we all editors? Hell no! Write away....no form, no agenda, no deadlines. And for the record, while I'm a big one for spelling and punctuation, I leave it at the door so-to-speak when I'm here; both while reading and writing. I absolutely feel the ........ and the ?! and , , , , are warranted when trying to convey the manner in which you are telling your entry.
Doesn't ....... mean a pause of sorts? And don't lots of ,,,, in the course of a sentence usually infer excitement and/or breathless account? I thought so, as I'm sure most others did too.
Go on, write with your unique and interesting style. I'm here for the meaning, not for the grammatical faux pas. Shit, I love that I'm not the only one who can care more about my words than how correct they are.
Well put, and I second it all,
Tammy
http://thestorycontinues-tschamberland.blogspot.com
http://www.myspace.com/tschamberland
your journal is yours:) don't ever let some one tell you how to write or what to say!! hope you had fun while you were gone i missed you
Deb
I say to these people... these critics... Phhhhhhhhhhht!!!!! Personally I'm just glad to have you back! So, let those words roll! <LOL>
Oh, and anyone who is going to critique writing style/grammer/excessive use of ...... had better not come visit me cause my Journal would drive them right up the wall and onto their last nerve <ROFL>
http://journals.aol.com/astaryth/AdventuresofanEclecticMind
http://adventuresofaneclecticmind.blogspot.com/
Wow, I've never had anyone criticize me for that type of thing. Why would someone do that? Hell if I know. I would want to ask that person "Do you correct the grammar of other people when they are speaking to you, too?"
You are a great blogger Rebecca. If someone is so insecure in their real life that they get their jollies playing "3rd grade English teacher", let them. Who cares, don't let it bother you.
I am so glad you have been back:)
Chris
http://inanethoughtsandinsaneramblings.blogspot.com
WTH... This is your space, Rebecca. I know I don't have to tell you that. I had someone try to tell me what I couldn't write in my journal. Screw that. It's a free damn country. I'm sorry, now I'm just pi$$ed. Your writing is all you. It's from the heart. It's real. Never change for anyone. I know you wouldn't anyway, but I also hope this doesn't make you want to stop writing. I always smile when I see an alert from you! Take care and stay the strong woman that you are.
Michelle
Wait! Am I to understand that people (multiple, that; more than just one?) have been, in some way, criticising the way you write in your journal? Did these people's parents not teach them any manners? If anyone ever tried to criticise stylistic choices I had made in my journal, I would have one phrase to offer them: "don't let the door hit your ass on the way out." Content, there is open season on, but style? Go shove it up yer hoo-haw!
Of course, my opinion is biased because I like the way you write here (although, having had a taste of what else you can do only whets my appetite for more of your more conventional writing as well), but if I didn't, I'd simply go elsewhere. With fifty plus million blogs out there, no one should ever feel the need to hang out at a place where they don't enjoy the available fare. So just tell the rudesters to hurry on their way, and leave those of us with a more discerning palate to savour what you feed us.
-Paul
http://journals.aol.ca/plittle/AuroraWalkingVacation/
What has helped me is to decide whether my journal is for me or for everyone else. I decided it is for me and that is the direction it takes. If people have problems with it oh well it's for me and not them. I pick and choose who I respond to. I'm not here to explan or justify myself. Happy to hear from everyone, but it is all just about me. ~ Mike
Good for you! It's your journal, your thoughts, your words... we always get the point, no matter it's written. I can't believe people would pick apart the words of your journal. Crazy!
http://boiseladie.blogspot.com/
When it comes to books I want to be caught up in another place and time. When It comes to journals I want it to be similar to a letter from that person. I thank God I don't get that kind of criticism at my journal. Lord only knows what they'd find! LOL But then the whole point of how I write is to try to let the people who read it feel like they have really visited Caneyhead, accent and all. Perhaps they pick on you because they know you are a "writer". If they bother you a bit, hit delete. If they bother you a lot, hit block. In the wise words of Ricky Nelson, "You can't please everyone, so you've got to please yourself."
You go, girl. I read your writing because it inspires - and that is most important of all.
Charley
http://journals.aol.com/cdittric77/courage
Hey YOU!
Ugh....I could feel these rumblings and how poetic you placed these words...
It is those negatives that always stand out. Always. Why?
Many reasons, for each are our own.
I am agast everytime, one, jus ONE feels the need to give opinion on feelings, thoughts that are internally personal. And when called out on it, get all on the defense. I dont get it. Nor ill I ever.
Rebecca I have missed you. Your words.
Maybe my thinking of you(and a few others) reached you somehow. Right about the time I was drafting an entry of me own, in regards to those I miss, you leave me a comment and then followed by 2 entries.
Write on. Good bad indifferent. Its yours, I am content in knowing you share(we share) a commonality.
Peace My dear friend!
Jo
Welcome back...It is so good to see you again.
This is YOUR journal. That says it all. Do what you want to do and the heck with those who disagree, or find fault. This is your space and anyone who comes here is a guest. You do not have to please others with what you have to say, or how you say it.
So.........the heck with the critiquers (sp?) GO GIRL!!! I look forward to reading your continuing stream of consciousness.
B.
http://journals.aol.com/benu4444/CreativityBitsandPieces/
If someone doesn't like the way you write, they don't have to read your writing. I enjoy it. I'm glad, very glad, you're back. If your critics don't like the way you write they can go ... stuff themselves.
Oh my gosh, I am so ready to cry now. I REALLY hope you are not referring to me. I did post a comment a few entries ago about how I had to scroll back and forth for each line because the formatting of the journal does not allow one to see a line all the way from one side to another on the screen. So I have to scroll left to right to see each line in its entirety each time for each line. Does this make sense? Do other readers have this issue? Maybe it is just my stupid computer or my own inadequacy in knowing how to manuever around. AND the ONLY reason I EVEN mentioned it was not because I was trying to critique you or pick on you but because I LOVE YOUR JOURNAL and wish it was easier for me to read. I guess this was very selfish of me but I really thought you might appreciate the feedback. I AM SO SORRY if I offended. Please no hard feelings. I probably did not make myself uderstood properly. YIKES!!
~Heidi
Rebecca...I know I only recently found your journal but oh my...do I love it...LOVE your writing style...LOVE IT!....I too dont focus on grammar perfection and some offer words of correction but for me, it doesnt bother me...I send responses like...blogging is fun and not my job...they mean well or at least the ones who've written me but you could probably find an error in every article I've written..I refuse to put out the energy to strive for perfection but rather content...as you say as well....In some ways...it keeps the focus on what we both want others to hear.......love your words Rebecca....I posted a poetry blog of mine....Now forewarn...its not poetry but it is...its my style...completely forbidden for those who think in grammar boxes or define writing by those who've written...
~Raven
I just came to visit your journal today for the first time and I really like your writing style. I think I am capable of taking your journal writing style in my stride with no complaints. I think it is your privilege to write here as you desire. I have been writing on our family web site for about three years and just recently we had a big discusson about editing our entries for grammar, spelling, etc. Cheryl, the niece who facilitates the web site, said she did not want any family members discouraged from writing an entry for fear they might not get those right! I applaud her thinking. I will have to refer her to your journal where she can read an indepth discussion of such, I think, very well expressed by the way. As I said I like your writing style! Gerry
http://journals.aol.com/gehi6/daughters-of-the-shadow-men/
By the way I could not get comments to your journal to show. Perhaps you might check it out to see if that feature is working properly.
Beautifully said!
Lori
At the risk of pissing you off -- this journal should be your book. From its Proustian title to your astonishing entries, I don't think you reallize YET its power. Instead I'm sure you think you're saving the good stuff for your book.
This is the good stuff.
It needs very little editing, a few MINOR corrections in grammar and spelling, and you're good to go.
Sorry if my email feedback was unwanted. Its intent was well meaning.
Mrs. L
Post a Comment