Tuesday, October 11, 2005

Concrete


A thought is just a thought, floating around in this abyss I call my mind.
Every thought has possibilities. Something powerful, or exploratory. Perhaps introspective or just an observation. Sometimes humorous or deeply emotional. Occasionally even painful or my essence of happiness.

In my world, writing is akin to pouring concrete.
A thought poured into writing, has all the chances of becoming solid form, but no matter how quickly I wish it would dry, there is a space of time that it is still wet and vulnerable. This concrete can be easily enhanced or marred by outside influences.

This is the risk to reward of writing in a public journal.

       Have you ever come across freshly poured concrete? Although there may be signs posted everywhere, "Caution Wet Cement" the natural inclination is to duck under the yellow tape and scratch your initials in the still drying matter. A delightful way of leaving your stamp on something that will become set in stone.


       That is how I view comments.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

       I have come across far too many entries in other peoples journals lately that have expressed personal dismay over comments or emails they have received from people that hurt them to the core. This saddens me to the core. (Edit note: No, I haven't received anything but wonderful amazing comments here on my journal and if I minus the one email I received informing me a person would no longer be reading my journal because of my Prayer entry, all is perfect in my neck of the woods.)

       I am not immune to mistakes and I made a terrible mistake commenting once on a journal myself. I followed this persons journal religiously and left encouraging comments over and over. Supportive and heartfelt wishes for someone dealing with many not so pleasant things. My mistake came when I crossed the line by reading an entry, becoming emotionally distraught over the writers situation and commenting in a more forceful, here are some possible solutions for you manner. I know I wrote my suggestions out of shear concern and frustration over the journals situation, but I crossed an invisible line with the writer.

       My reward for my comment was a searing entry wrote the next day that ripped my concern and idea's to shreds. Although I was horrified that my comment had evoked such a tirade from another person, and I was deeply hurt that my concern was mocked as such, I learned an invaluable lesson.

       I learned that instead of scratching my initials in the writers cement, I had taken the liberty of placing one big old foot print mark in her world. Without realizing it, I ignored the yellow caution tape and stepped in her wet cement. Did I think the writer handled my misstep in a good way? Not at all. Have I ever commented there again? Nope, no thanks, because I believe the writer crossed a line with me too. Will I remember that little atrocity my entire timeline of public journal writing, your damn right I will~~ Two stomped on slabs of concrete is never a good thing.

       I believe words are the most powerful thing in the universe. Perhaps, some don't view words as such or understand the meaning of that sentence. Through words a person can convey something powerful, meaningful or insignificant.

       Through the power of words you can make a persons day, or with one un-thought sentence you can break them. Some of the most devious voices in my mind aren't thoughts I conjured up, but something someone said to me once, that I haven't been able to remove from memory, my concrete.

       When those words come to the forefront of my mind, I have to wonder sometimes if the person who said them, whether two years ago or ten years ago, would have said them if they knew I would never be able to forget their stomping in my concrete. That concrete dried, with their marks firmly set in stone. Tis a fact I cannot ignore. 

       That brings me back to comments. I find comments to be priceless gifts granted to me. Through comments I have discovered so many beautiful things about people, myself, and the world around me. I have discovered probably the most beautiful thing of all.

I am not alone. I am not alone...............

       Maybe this entry is just a reminder to myself to use caution when reading other people thoughts. The freshlypoured concrete is delicate and can be manipulated for enhanced beauty or it can be stomped on with possible permanent impressions. Journals are so unbelievably personal, they are the very lifeline into our inner workings, a privileged peek that really isn't surpassed in any other manner. It's the care and respect to the writer that needs to be adhered to above and beyond anything we might be personally thinking about said topic when commenting.

And thats just my wet cement of thoughts, always ready and accepting of the initials and impressions. Just no stomping please~~

And to Jodi    Looking Beyond the Cracked Window....  Thank you so much for your beautiful entry and poem. I will hold those concrete words near and dear to my heart forever~

43 comments:

Anonymous said...

I can't ever imagine you writing something that wasn't heartfelt. Every comment I've ever gotten from you has been wonderful. I too, sometimes, find myself with my foot hovering over the cement. I never know where that line is and when it shouldn't be crossed. It's hard to judge, but I try to my best to be as supportive and understanding as possible when it comes to commenting. It never ceases to amaze me how you say exactly what I think.

And if I have ever left a comment that has crossed a line, I would expect you to tell me. I do apologize if I have. It all comes from a good place, I promise.

You are so not alone on this one.

Ari

Anonymous said...

I've noticed that lately. Where people are having problems with comments in journals. I'm not perfect either...I try to be light-hearted when I leave my comment, because it's not my place to judge. I can give unwanted advice, sure, but to judge, that's not my place.

I've noticed people are becoming overly obsessed with comments. On the boards, people asking for comments...when did journals become a performance show? And calling people who read your journal "fans"? I don't get that either.

Admittedly there are journals geared just for that. But still...

Before I got picked for journal of the week, I still wrote in my journal, and if I never got picked, and no one ever saw what I wrote, I'd still write the same stuff in it that I do now.

Don't get me wrong, I love comments (even yours) because it's nice to know you relate to other people in this AOL world, but I just think sometimes we lose sight of what this is about, to write for yourself, and if someone loves what you write even more the better.

Did I stomp the cement too much? I hope not. Oh and whenever you want to call me out on some spew I write, please do it. I expect no less from anyone who looks at my stuff.

Anonymous said...


"... care and respect... above and beyond anything..."

If you intend to withstand that, tell me 'precisely' what you want to read, love. And, at least this once, I'll write it for you.

... I think that much of you, Rebecca.

~Fondly, Brian @---->---

PS: You may always remain my favorite writer in J-Land.

http://journals.aol.com/thelovetrain/tracks/

Anonymous said...

Rebecca....I had about three (or more) personas run through my head to comment...my silly side, that ever broody serious side...
I am going with the understanding, acceptance all with an open mind open heart.
Comments are wonderful, inspiring and for me? A tool to learn. TO feed this incessant monster in my head that just gets enough! It is when that tool is abused and it is no longer reflecting the writing or the entry. It becomes a direct slam on the individual, that irks me...Maybe I do just look through a cracked window too much. I really really try to understand or to just give where the giving is meant to be. I know, you know that there are always going to be those we disagree with, in our own comments section or in someone elses.
Words are more powerful than some give them credit. THere are no delete buttons. Man do we wish there were. I have never found any of your entries or comments ones to take offense. If anything, I have walked away with some knowledge or thought to look at something in a new light. Learn me, I learn you.

THis was written very beautifully! I told you, you'd accomplish this much better than I..lol.
And again...You are welcome! I am very touched for the nod. THANK YOU.....you are a constant inspiration for me. I am happy I was able to impart some Joy today!
These words are for you, forever!
Peace
Jo

Anonymous said...

What a great entry!!  I am cautious about what I say in comments, because spoken words carry inflections, and emotion, and the written word is flat and can be taken any way the reader wishes to.  "Have a great day" has a totally different meaning if said with sarcasm.  Anyway, I loved your entry, very well said!!
~~Kath~~

Anonymous said...

In my opinion, it's always best to remember there is a human being who may have strong, and possibly sensitive, feelings on the other side of the computer screen.  Sometimes people forget that, or sometimes they just get caught up in what they want to say to the author and forget how their words may be taken.

This is a great entry that you've written...worded very well.  :)

Anonymous said...

This is such a wonderful entry...it's so true in how you discribe how comments can and usually do make the journaler feel.  In this media, that is what we base everything on is the written word, and so a lot goes into what we write in our journals..they are very personal to us. And receiving comments that are hurtful can be devastating to some.

http://journals.aol.com/derasta/MyBigFatGreekLife/

Anonymous said...

Our journals expose our wet concrete all the time. I feel that comments should be well thought out based upon the entry commented on. Or else the journaller may get confused or take it as an oblique insult. It is so easy to do when there is no face or body language to attach a comment to. One single word out of place, or quotation marks around the wrong word in a sentence can cause a misunderstanding. Ofcourse, there are intentional insults & angry comments in J-land, too.  Words can be like rocks thrown at someone, or like balm on a painful wound. Most of us care what others think.

Anonymous said...

Such a simple thing "concrete" Until this entry. I am inspired....

Anonymous said...

I always think of comments as a way i can learn more about myself , my reaction to them , my joy or dismay at them only helping me on my journey of discovering who i really am, constructive is always better than destructive of course , serious 10 liner quotes or funny one liners i soak them all up and take them for what they are , just as i am free to write what i want so too is everyone else free to comment .
I love this entry and its take on the whole situation x

Anonymous said...

Beautifully written. And I wouldn;t argue with a word you said right there
http://journals.aol.co.uk/slinkycharlotte/Thedinkiestmaelstromisland-sideo/

Anonymous said...

You are so incredibly eloquent!  I talk more like this in real life versus the inane slang inspired banter I write here.  Wonderful. ;)  C.  http://journals.aol.com/gdireneoe/thedailies

Anonymous said...

Once again you eloquently discussed a topic that is not easily communicated.  Thank you for reminding me to think before I hit the "Save" button.
Lovely ode by Jodi!  I'm in your field...
A reader stopped reading your journal because of your "Prayer" entry?  Oh my, I'm sorry, I feel so responsible, Rebecca!
Judith
http://journals.aol.com/jtuwliens/MirrorMirrorontheWall

Anonymous said...

Here's to a well put journal entry!  And here's my little signiture in concrete - Julie -

Anonymous said...

Love reading your journal thanks for sharing:)

Deb

Anonymous said...

Huh, thank you.  Great entry and wonderful advice...

I loved Jodi's poem!

Be well,
Dawn

Anonymous said...

Such a thoughtful entry here, Rebecca!  You make so many great points.  One that crossed my mind is that when we make a "comment" to someone in real life, they add your voice inflection and other non-verbal cues to the message you sent them.  

When we comment in Jland, the only thing the person receives is the written word, absent of the other intended communications we normally use (an up turned eyebrow, a smile, etc).  

I would hate to think I've ever hurt someone's feelings with a comment.  I've only ever intended them as positive.  

Leaving now.....no footprints.

Chris
http://journals.aol.com/swibirun/Inanethoughtsandinsaneramblings
http://www.bigoven.com/~swibirun

Anonymous said...

I'm sure that you meant well in your comments to the writer....I can not imagine you meaning to be any other way.  This person must have over analyzed what you were saying, becoming extremely sensitive while enduring a difficult time in their life.  Words may be set in stone, and sometimes unknowingly we hurt someone, but there is a very important thing called forgiveness in life.  We all make mistakes.  Michelle

Anonymous said...

Very, very interesting and timely, for me....I've just entered J-Land and this thought crossed my mind the other night.....I was wondering if there would be a time when I cross the line because I tend to overly express myself, meaning well.  This will definitely be a reminder for me......Thanks!   chris

Anonymous said...

Hmmm, wondering if it was the same person that attacked my suggestion?  Did the name begin with 'E'?    ;)

Well written and truly informative....

I think we've all put our (writing) foot in our mouth, at some point.  I know I have!

Actually, I made a complete fool of myself here before :)

Ah well, I'm still alive ;)

Cat

Anonymous said...

And at the same time, I find so much support and love here, and this has been a fantastic community.
Peace and love,
Charley
http://journals.aol.com/CDittric77/Courage

Anonymous said...

I always love comments, but I'm kind of like Oscar Wilde in that regard - "There's one thing worse than being talked about - and that's not being talked about."  I hope to not get stomped on too much, and I hope I don't cross lines - here or anywhere else.

Anonymous said...

Good evening.......That person doesn't realize what a wonderful person you truly are. I enjoy your journal and I enjoy reading your writing. I feel that you are a talented inspiring writer with a real insight to keeping a journal. I think that if readers such as myself didn't have your journal to read that would really be something quite awful. Your true readers like myself find that visiting your journal is like opening a good book that we can't put down until the very end. I can't stop visiting your journal even if I wanted to which I don't. I want to keep coming back to your journal every chance I get. I am a reader of your journal and you have made me feel welcome in more ways than one. Your journal is a must read for anyone who appreciates good writing..........

You are definitely not alone your readers which happens to include myself are waiting to read more of your journal........Please keep writing !!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

I agree with you about comments. I leave them and I kind of speak how I feel, so far it hasn't gotten me in trouble.  I would think just about anything you would write would be thoughtful & caring...so don't be too hard on yourself...Sandi http://journals.aol.com/sdoscher458/LifeIsFullOfSurprises

Anonymous said...

"I love you".  "I'm sorry".  Two of the most difficult phrases in the English language to say face-to-face, yet sincerity comes easily in J-land.  From reading your journal, I can see that every entry is written with an authentic and heart-filled perspective of life.  It reflects your natural curiosity about humanity, and it's always a pleasure to read.

~Kris

Anonymous said...

I must say Rebecca...(yes I am back as well ) that it is still ruminating....
I think all the comments are wonderful and that field is full!

I enjoy the fact that people are honest and say what they feel...I really really do. My point here on this? It is when the writer is "attacked" (for a lack of a better term right now) Where the comment is personal. Where I feel the focus should be on the writing and the message!

It's nice to have our own and then realizze we do share with others.

Peace
Jodi

Anonymous said...

I really like your writing style, the metaphors are great.  Didn't you write something in your journal about writing a book.  I hope you get it published.

Charles

Anonymous said...

What an outstanding way of explaining and comparing comments left behind in our journals has permenant marks that could be a stomp of a foot, the curve of a bum, the imprint of a chest from a hug, or high five of a hand!! Now, I can only start to get creative on this one here along with you and say my imprint is a total body dive smiling face down with hair flowing in the wind to the side on the cement on all your inputs and great big fancy signature from little ole me!~ HA! :)
Renee' @

Anonymous said...

At times I am ashamed to say it is my own thoughts that often prevent me from writing.  You always write with such honesty, exploring the very things thoughtful people struggle with each day.  May your thoughts always flow, without hesitation, so your words can enrich the lives of many.  

Well done Rebecca.  Give yourself an 'Atta Girl!'  :)  

Dona
http://journals.aol.com/delela1/BlueSkiesandGentleBreezes

Anonymous said...

Wow, you write with such honesty and openess.

I wish I could think of comments more like your way.  I confess that mostly I'm just relieved when I get any.  I'm always afraid an entry is going to sit there, commentless and alone.  Like I gave a part of myself and no one cared.  Which isn't the greatest attitude. ;-)  

See you gave me something to think about!
Donna

Anonymous said...

Wow 30 comments, with me makes 31. I know that I might just have started this journal thing. But all I have to say is that because it is our journals we should be able to say whatever is in our thoughts and minds. Even what is in our hearts, if we make it public we should not be so naive to think that it will all me pleasant. However you and those who has read my journal have not let any negative comments. The lost is with those who can't see when there is an innocent, kind gesture coming from you. Please don't hold anything back when it comes to leaving me a comment, I perfer for you to always remain true. ~j~

Anonymous said...

I enjoy your journal so much and your honesty that I couldn't leave without letting you know that I have added your journal to my other journal list. So that others will hopefully enjoy it as much as I. Please feel free to add me to your list, you are always welcome.....~j~

Anonymous said...

"Through words a person can convey something powerful, meaningful or insignificant.
Through the power of words you can make a persons day, or with one un-thought sentence you can break them....."

You know what I am feeling right now? I am very grateful to know you through your journal. Thank you for sharing your wonderful insights, thank you for letting us peek into your beautiful world and thank you for showering us with your eloquent writings.
Take care,
Gem :-)

Anonymous said...

wow.
hopefully these words are nothing but encouraging.
I've only just got into this world of journals, only last week, so i feel somewhat out of my depth when i read an entry such as this one. But it made me smile, and it made me think, and it made me want to write more in mine. Thanks!
James
journals.aol.co.uk/lejamz/ThingsISee

Anonymous said...

well said. judi

Anonymous said...

Sometimes I will have a person who has always commented in my jnl just stop.....I always wonder if I offended them in some way! Words without inflection can be easily misunderstood.

Anonymous said...

Beautiful entry.   You are always so eloquent and manage to express my own thoughts so well.  Thanks.  Paulette

Anonymous said...

I've had my own epiphany this week regarding comments, and entries, and leaving comments on entries that have resulted in becoming the brunt of a joke as a result of a comment taken badly as a result of an entry, and then having a huge misunderstanding with another gentle soul as a result of a well-intended, but taken incorrectly comment that was a response to another comment from a comment related to the other comment!
Great balls of fire, we are dealing with the stuff that pentecostal ministers wouldn't dare even speak about from their pulpits, LOL!
In the end, the episode was cathartic and I am much wiser for it all. For you are so right in what you have said about the power of words.
The writer of the written word takes on an enormous responsibility as a result of that power. We all need to be cognizant of that as we put our words out into the open for all the world to see.
I am a sadder but wiser girl as a result of only finding this out quite recently.
Thank-you for an extremely thoughtful, concise, (as it can be with a subject of this magnitude!) and well-written summary of what we all somehow know on a subconcious level, but oftentimes need a lesson in, so that we can take it more seriously in the future.
Maryanne
PS: Glad I am finally catching up with your thought-provoking entries!

Anonymous said...

I wholeheartedly agree with you...

our words can destroy whole nations
and break entire spirits....

be careful and
tread lightly

very, very lightly

there are hearts beat beneath the concrete....

Christina

Anonymous said...

I have decided to follow suit and deleted all my enty alerts.  It's so refreshing,  like no pressure whatsoever.  I go where and when I choose.  I'm sorry to have been away so long,  it's been a bit hectic around here.  

This entry did something for me in the respect that we both had an epiphany about comments.  

I decided to get rid of all the fluff.    I also have posted an entry about comments over at Tidbits,  just today in fact.  And I was shocked and pleased to see and read your entry about the subject.  

and this:

In my world, writing is akin to pouring concrete.
A thought poured into writing, has all the chances of becoming solid form, but no matter how quickly I wish it would dry, there is a space of time that it is still wet and vulnerable. This concrete can be easily enhanced or marred by outside influences.

is so well put.  The image is so,  well...concrete.  ;)

SINS

Anonymous said...

    There is so much truth in this entry.  It is so easy, when we are reading someone's abbreviated words and phrases, to mistake their meaning.  I try to remind myself while I'm in here, that when something someone says sounds rude or brash, I need to look back at my past experiences with this person.  If what they are saying sounds out of character with my previous encounters with them, then there is a better than average chance that one of two things happened.  Either I misread.... or they miswrote .  Better to give the benefit of the doubt, I think.  Thanks for an interesting and thought-provoking entry.  Tina http://journals.aol.com/onemoretina/Ridealongwithme

Anonymous said...

This is my first time reading your journal. I am... simply... blown away by your words. You are an amazing writer and I am impressed with the elegant, yet strong voice in which you write. Your journal is one where I will start at the beginning.

Great entry... very well said.

~Jaime
jaimechase.com

Anonymous said...

You are such a wonderful writer. It's so difficult a task to do at times. Well meaning comments can so easily be taken totally in the wrong context or interpreted as something totally unintended. This is the frustration I often find with e-mail as well. A fine tightrope we sometimes travel upon.