Friday, June 24, 2005

"Said Topic"

       I have been trying to do a simple entry this entire week, about what I would classify as one hell of a hot button topic. I've wrote it, edited it, twisted it, revamped it and basically it's giving me such fits I've jumped ship, and this is me hanging on by one hand, to the anchor.
      
        So what is the problem you may ask? And that folks is the key question. The problem is my views on a universal issue are in the minority seats of the stadium. Therefore, my opinions on said topic are usually kept quite personal to avoid the instant gape of mouth, sigh of "oh girl your going to that place," and the sometimes blatant backlash that can be dished out.
     
        It is the backlash of my position that ruffled my feathers last week <in the 3-d world> , and this is why my thoughts have been itching to write about it, while my mind has been marching a most beautiful protest. So in my last and final attempt, I will attempt a compromise between the opposing teams here in my mind.

       Exclusion and judgment is the key words. Exclusion based on a pre-formed opinion, and judgment handed down based on a quick unified decision. This is what a group of 9 woman (mommies) in my youngest daughters class, have done since she started Kindergarten 5 years ago. An honest me, will admit I call them the Cult 9 and I will defend that well earned label without guilt. From the second day of school, way back then, I was asked point blank my position on said hot topic, my honest response, was the word "No." This was followed up with a phone call to me personally 3 days later inviting me to said organization, of which I politely declined. This bought me and my daughter a one way ticket into the exclusion and judgment villa.

       Typically, being left out of said Cult 9 would be an exclusion I would never loose sleep over. But it has certainly been something my young daughter has felt and not understood. How does a Mother explain to a 5 year old that because Mommy doesn't conform to said specific topic, she has grown imaginary horns and the cult 9 must shield their children away from such blasphemy? My child suffered because of guilt by association. How you may wonder? A fine example would be a 8 yr. old Kaitlyn coming home after school and saying "Mommy, Janea said if we would go to 'said place" then she would be allowed to play with me on the playground." An interesting position to be in that I never dreamed in this day and age would be necessary.

       With the precision of a surgeon, I have explained to my daughters that unfortunately some people in this world become entwined so deeply in not necessarily said topic, but the organization of which they belong, that blind folds are centered nicely on their eye's and mind. I feel, that while staying true to oneself's beliefs, if one person <or a Cult 9> becomes intolerable to other beliefs, they loose sight of what should be the ultimate destination. Isn't the ultimate destination the divine Grand Daddy question of them all?

       The unleashing and reasoning for said entry.
       While at the local swimming pool last week, with me resting on comfy chaise lounge with book in hand, and the Cult carefully positioned on the other side of the pool, <yes this town is that small> I had a visitor.

            Cult 9 is now, Cult 8, they have experienced a defection in the posse. Apparently this defector, started back to College last year, experienced liberation in woman's studies and has filed for divorce, claiming being married is akin to slavery. She figured I would be a good allied force, since she too had grown horns and been accused of blasphemy. Now, this woman had never said more then 5 actual sentences to me over the previous 5 years, and now I'm considered worthy? That would be my first irritation.

       As an observer and digger of information, I listened for at least an hour, glancing at the Cult 8 on the other side of the pool, watching their stares and glares, before grilling questions on this poor unprepared defector. Growing horns had not taken away her honesty and she did indeed admit it had been decided 5 years back to blatantly keep away from me and instruct their children to stay away from my daughter, yes, they had stamped a big red X on my forehead just as I had figured. I could write for an hour about the interesting revelations I revealed through my intense interrogation,but I fear this is already too long.

       The Moral of the story.
       In the case of "said topic" which I have carefully been able to avoid actual naming, I would like to point a few things out. I have no blinders on, I am perfectly comfortable with the notion that every single person on this planet has distinct personal views on several facets of their life. I wouldn't dare accuse one person of being wrong and me being right, or the other way around, choice is individual. 

     That is the BEAUTIFUL thing about free will. I believe the word and color gray should be spelled that way. Some people feel it should be spelled grey. I completely respect choice to my core. It's a choice. If you look at "said topic" there are so many choices to be found and the levels of belief are astounding. From zero belief to deep core devotion. I find that a beautiful thing and make every attempt to understand both. My circle of acceptance really is 360 degrees, and it's a good place to be.
     
       What I have a very hard time accepting is when one level of belief trumps all others and the degree in which people look out at others is narrowed into some sort of 30 degree channel. How does one group chant moral do right, yet, exile another group without any sort of encompassing understanding of choice? Hypocrisy at it's finest. Wars have been waged on such narrowly defined causes. I am also not blind enough to think all "said topics" are like the Cult 9, correction, Cult 8 now. I am a singleton in my views and typically stand alone in my choice, but have SO MANY "said topic"  friends and family who embrace me nonetheless. That is the acceptance I love to emulate. The burr I realized I allowed a select group to place between my foot and shoe has been replaced with a nice soft cushion of pity.
      
       Perhaps, I am a dreamer, or an optimist, who believes that as long as I carry high moral values, adhere to a strong code of ethics, I stand in a good place. Perhaps, the world isn't really ready for acceptance of all walks of choice and open 360 degree views. I wouldn't dream of telling another person their choice of anything was wrong. There is too much to admire in diversity of humanity. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. I hover between a heaven, and the earth I stand on, and you know, it's a mighty fine view. 
             

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

As one mom to another, I tried for a short time to play like I accepted the "club" view, in my mind, for the sake of my daughter. However, as many folks will tell you, you do a disservice to your children when you are not "real", whatever that may mean. I gained the courage to "come out" on "said topic" and lost the club, but gained respect and interest from my kids, which then fostered open discussions of various paths and how and why I chose mine. My children know that I will say what I mean no matter the cost to me. I have seen in my eldest daughter an ability to stand on her feet so to speak when she disagrees with the majority... that tells me I did the right thing. JMO...Penny

Anonymous said...

Well I think both of you ladies are wonderful examples of what a real woman is.
I applaud your willingness to stand up for what you beleive in.
And I congradulate you on your successes.
I am very very proud of you.

Anonymous said...

Hmm. The veil on this one is thin, methinks. Translation: you're not hiding anything in your oh so careful tap dancing around naming "the place." I bet you've even been called 'closed minded.' You are going to be sooooo happy you published this article today.
;)
-Paul
http://journals.aol.ca/plittle/AuroraWalkingVacation/

Anonymous said...

Rebecca,
I agree with you on this. I believe in not condemning others just because their views are different with mine. It doesn't make sense to me when a certain group act like they're popular, that I need to hang out with them yet condemn me just because I am not up to their standard. Oh..gosh..you got me started LOL!
Anway, you speak well of your values and you've put into word what I have been wondering all along about "cliche". It's sad that the kids get involved but it's more important to show the kids what your values are and stand up for it than give in to a certain group just so you or your children would "fit in."
Wonderful entry!
Gem ;-)
http://journals.aol.com/libragem007/JournallyYours

Anonymous said...

.............................
.............................thinking of the words
.............................
this is a powerful essay and I am so glad that you got it down. I well remember the cadre of moms who did things ONE WAY and when I came along I really JANGLED THEIR NERVES. What was humorous to me was that it was numerous things about me, not just one or two beliefs. I live differently from some people, now MUCH differently, and some people are threatened by that.
You are a good person, standing on your two feet.... just as you are. I enjoyed your thought process here. Good for you. judi

Anonymous said...

Ahhh... Been a victim of the playgroup groupthink, huh?  Been there, and like you I was branded a conservative in a liberal world or vice versa. I was neither, I am just committed to my convictions.  Like you, in the end, I chose to be alone instead of playing mind games.

Anonymous said...

All pretty wierd, and pretty uncomfortable I would imagine.  I can't imagine what could be so divisive among the playdate set.  But maybe I'm just lacking in imagination.

Anonymous said...

first of all you make me crazy not naming "said topic". second, I truly feel sorry for the cult since they are so terrified of new thoughts they must isolate their children. third, I am indignanant...what person of any morals would be cruel to a child under any pretext? I would be very uncomfortable in that situation.
Marti

Anonymous said...

Welcome to the minority section, love... all the better to have you here :)

Even without naming it, I can bet what it is about... but so many of the hot topics can be substituted, I wouldn't dare guess.

For some reason, I keep believing that we of free will out number those who aren't, until I see people being excluded in free and public institutions of education and elsewhere.  

But it is tales like these that make my desire to homeschool my daughter even greater!  Why should she even be exposed to such nonsense?

Glad you stood your ground....

Cat

Anonymous said...

Gee Rebecca, if I'd known all along that you were one of THEM and not one of US, I would never have been commenting in your journal!  My mum told me to stay away from THEM.  ;)

Chris
http://journals.aol.com/swibirun/Inanethoughtsandinsaneramblings
http://journals.aol.com/swibirun/MyJournalJarSaturdaySixetcanswer

Anonymous said...

Coming from the highest level of the Kangeroo Courts is that ol' familiar lowest level playground yap. Parents who act out as such just haven't had enough humility yet and trust me when I say this " I promise they will, it is a reality yet to be lived for them."
Raising the boys it didn't take me long to see that those years are much like a roulette wheel spinning in circles and everyone's number is on it.
Wishing you health, happiness and laughter.
TJ~

http://journals.aol.com/vaultofsecrets/MoonDancer/

Anonymous said...

I'm not entirely 100% sure what "said topic" is, but I have a good idea.

You say you are in the minority, which causes you to speak in riddles and not come right out with it. I can understand not wanting backlash, but I know you are a strong woman.

What if Rosa Parks just gave up her seat on the bus, because of the fear of backlash?

I think you are a person that doesn't like to stir the pot - and that's okay. Just please don't act like your opinions are not as worthy of being heard as everyone else's just for the simple fact that they are different. I happen to like the differences in people. I may or may not agree with your opinion, but I most certainly CAN respect where you are coming from.

As for Cult 9 (8), there are always going to be people that think their "stuff" doesn't stink. You don't need them. Perhaps exclusion from them is not so bad, eh? It must be lonely at the top of their mountain.

Ari

Anonymous said...

Hmmm... well, I know that I don't conform to majority beliefs on several 'said topics'. Probably yours as well <LOL>! Nice essay. Oh, and congrats on being one of the editor's picks this week!

Anonymous said...

Congrats on being an Editor's pick.  :)

Ana~

Anonymous said...

THAT was an awesome entry.  It hit close to home.  Three cheers that you are NOT a Cult 8 member and damn proud of it.  Your daughter may not understand it now, but in the long run (and that's what matters most) she will, and she will thank you for teaching her.  She will be stronger for it.  Michelle :o)

Anonymous said...

wow.. now I see what you were talking about.  what a poor example and shame on these women.  I can not imagine me myself, excluding my children from playing with another child because a mom didn't fit into a certain mold. (for 5 YEARS.. THAT IS JUST RIDICULOUS!) If anything I would love them even more and reach out, just because that is what it's all about, relationships and love.

Much Love,
Mary

Anonymous said...

I have to admit that I experienced this as a child in our small minded little town... right up through my senior year of high school.  My catholic mother married a protestant and because she did that and didn't raise her kids catholic, she was shunned and I had a friend that was not allowed to come to our home.  It was never a statement of the quality of my family but rather only a statement of the stupid arrogant narrow minds of these religious fanatics.
I too have a hard time thinking of a supreme being.  It makes no sense to me.  I do trust what the animals tell me though, and they speak of past lives and energy that is the source of all of us.  What they speak of has become the foundation of my spiritual beliefs.  I don't trust human religious institutions.
Peace,  Virginia

Anonymous said...

Talk about midddle school behavior. how childish of them!
Peace and Love,
Charley
http://journals.aol.com/CDittric77/Courage

Anonymous said...

Oh, the dreaded exclusion and judgement villa!  I know the place intimately!  I continue to question why some people can be so narrow.  Life (like love) is never black and white.  Living occurs in the gray/grey area.  The infinite shades of gray are beautiful, it's a continuum of lovely beliefs, ideas, and experiences.  Put them all together and they overshadow and overpower the black and white.  I've said it before and I'll continue to say it, "Who among us have the monopoly on moral do right?"  
Excellent and thought provoking entry!
Best,
Judith
http://journals.aol.com/jtuwliens/MirrorMirrorontheWall

Anonymous said...

I can imagine what said topic might be, but regardless, you are a rarity.  Sticking to your beliefs and not conforming for the sake of acceptance is admirable and inspiring.  More people should make that a regular practice, and we would soon find ourselves being accepted and accepting of others based on the whole and not the 'one view'.  Kudos my friend.
Tammy

Anonymous said...

Oh I have stood on the outside looking in at a large number of groups...I guess at a young age I just determined that I would not put up with crap.  Oh, thats not to say that I haven't joined in when it benefitted a good cause...doing that gladly, but the daily innuendos of bored housewifes never, ever appealed to me.  I think I had my parents telling me too often "If everybody jumped off the Brooklyn Bridge you would too!"....always made me want to do the opposite! LOL....enjoy your writings....Sandi  http://journals.aol.com/sdoscher458/LifeIsFullOfSurprises