Back in the days..............
Ben and I, camping, enjoying hot chocolate with our trusted BB guns. Siblings. I've observed how many of my friends have evolved within their own family structure to elevate what was once a pesky sister or brother, to that of friendship, closeness, family. I meander around online journals, reading of family bonds, sisterly and brotherly ties.
One amazing example is a journal I can't get enough of by Jtuwliens, Judith at Mirror, Mirror on the Wall/jtuwliens . The bonds she shares with her twin sister, Julie, is just inspiring, fascinating, heartwarming and frankly precious, especially to someone like me.
I have a brother. It's a rarity I mention it, it's odd to even write that. He is two years younger then I and we have no relationship to speak of. A honest me, will have to say, however bad it sounds, that I have chosen a long time ago, not to include him in my life.
I have a legitimate reason, I really do, and I'll get to it. I saw my brother this week for the first time since Christmas Eve of 2003. So naturally he's been on my mind and I think an entry is in order to release some of my thoughts. My brother was always a strange duck. Growing up with him was challenging a lot of the time. He had many learning disorders, social skills weren't similar to most mainstream humans, 1 plus 1 equaled 2 in my world, in his world it meant 5 and he would come out fists flailing to prove it. By the time he got to high school he found sanctuary in the name of drugs and alcohol.
But didn't a lot of us? I had my 2 years 9 months of crazy party, have fun, antics and thankfully I came out alive and healthy. My brother on the other hand, used drugs and alcohol for his personal escape from his ADHD, social disorders, low self esteem, etc., etc.......you name it, at least one doctor diagnosed him with it.
My poor parents. Beaver Cleaver kind of parents. Never smoked anything in their life, drinking wasn't something we ever saw them do growing up, they were stable, simple people who ended up with a teenage daughter who took parting with friends over the top for a few years, and a son who had disorders in every direction and eventually made their lives hell.
By the time Ben, my brother, was about 20 he had took to drinking like a fish in water. He elevated himself to alcoholic status in no time flat. This is when I truly believe I started loosing him as a brother. To understand his level of alcoholism, you need the cold hard facts. He would steal, pawn, take anything of value in order to get his alcohol. He would drink and drive without regard to life at hand. He managed to get 3 drunk driving tickets <stealing my parents cars> by the time he was 21. Thankfully, the worst he ever did was take out someone's fence. He was reduced to a bicycle by the time he was 21, lost his license for 9 years, spent a good amount of time in jail, etc., etc.........He was still living at my parents house. I HATED that.
He is a mean drunk. Uncontrollable mean. My parents tried to help him. If I knew the true amount of money my parents put into his rehabilitation, courts, lawyers, fines, bus passes and bicycles <remember, he'd just pawn his bike if he needed money> doctors, counselors, I bet they are still paying it off. They had to put a dead bolt lock on their bedroom door to keep them locked away from him if he was on a binge drunk.
I hated it. I would go over there and beg my parents to kick him out, send him to live under the bridgeby the river in town, I didn't care,I just couldn't stand to see them live like that in their own home. It was my Mother, as I imagine all Mothers would, who held on, trying to help him, bring him back from the hell he had placed himself.
Two very defining moments triggered the final move out. First, my Father was in Germany for a month <he's military> and my Mother was alone with my brother. He was on one of his drunk binges and called the police at 2 in the morning, to inform them he had a gun, was going upstairs to kill my Mother, then himself. Talk about a cry for help to stop him. The police swat teamed my parents house, found my Mothers bedroom window, broke it and drug her out of her sleep to the outside. They could see my Brother through the basement window on his bed with a pistol in his mouth. He never made a move to go upstairs to fulfill what he had told the police on the phone, and eventually fell asleep with the gun beside him. That got him 4 months in the crazy ward.
Next came release, and where does he go. A plan was formed, my parents bought him a little trailer house, far from their home, and when he got out, he could go there and live his life of alcoholism. There ended up being a 3 week span between release from the ward, and move in date. Yes, they let him come home to stay. It was Thanksgiving, he hadn't drunk for months, he swore he wouldn't drink....ya ya....same old story. Thanksgiving he started drinking, and by that Sunday he was out of control again. A fight ensued, threats were made, police came again....back to jail this time after giving the police one hell of a manhunt chase.
I was the one who picked him up from jail, took him to his new home, dropped him off and said "have a good life." It took five years for him to come around again. My father was the mainly the one who checked in on him, and occasionally I was asked to go make sure he was still alive. My Mother, even if this is hard for others to understand, thankfully did not talk to him in that 5 years. My Father and I begged her not too. The fall of 2003 he begged for help again and thats where I spent 4 months going to AA meetings with him, financially helping him, giving him odd jobs, because he was actually sober for once. After the third month of sober, on my own discretion, I decided he was far enough on the good side to visit my Mother again. It was a tearfulreunion, heartwrenching actually.
Sober, my brother is a completely different person. Sweet, kind, considerate, wonderful with kids, still alittle odd, but good. Drunk he is evil, mean. Two completely different people. The night before Thanksgiving that 2003, the first Thanksgiving he would have been able to go to after all those years, he got drunk, got in a fight with his girlfriend, took a knife to himself, and put his arm through a window nearly slicing his arm off. I got the call from the hospital at 1 in the morning. I spent Thanksgiving eve, at the hospital, I spent Thanksgiving Day, had my Thanksgiving dinner, back at the crazy ward again.
He got released before Christmas and I had put so much heart and soul into my brother that fall I was so hopeful he could at least do Christmas Eve with the family. We had talked, he swore he wouldn't drink a drop that day, because I told him if he did, he couldn't come. I showed up to pick him up that night. He was drunk. Enough said.
He looked good this week. He's managed to hold down a job now for over a year. He's still with the same girlfriend. She has so many problems of her own, the two are perfect for each other. He still drinks, he's still two different people. I just don't think I have it in me to step into his circle again. It's a travesty of emotion, it's a drain of life and breaks my heart. This passage of an entry is showing the bare roots of things that happened over the years, the list could go on for pages.........
So when people ask me if I have any brothers or sisters, sometimes I will say yes, sometimes I say no. Because the person who should be my brother belongs to alcohol. I'm not sure if I'll ever reclaim him from the disease that holds him firmly in it's grasp. I mourn for my loss, my daughters loss of an Uncle, my parents loss of a son. It's a long twisted road that I find difficult to explain so people understand how one family could walk away from a blood family member. I see it as a forced choice. One that I am good with.
Long entry, sorry about that. Just felt the need to get the visit, reaffirm my thoughts and the events, my loss, off my mind and into relic form.

26 comments:
Hugs to you. I know this hasn't been easy.
As I wipe the tears in my eyes, I wish to jump through the computer with a big, vurtual hug to you. Did you get it??
You can't pick you family, but you can pick you friends. Stay strong, reflect on the good memories. - Julie -
Rebecca
Love, we share so much, I to am estranged from my siblings, for similar reasons. Most of the time i don't think abou them, but sometimes it all comes back at once...with a lot of pain. I can remember who they were before the chose the road they went down...it was a dark one and they wouldn't allow real help, just the kind of help that enables one in distructive behavior. I am guessing you know what I mean. (((((Rebecca)))) from one sib to another.
Love, Carly
oh,there is so much heartache in this entry. I am in tears for you. Your poor mom.that is such a sad story.I wish I could say something to make it a little better.
Marti
Rebecca,
A chilling entry, for me personally. Gave me goosebumps but also let me know this is about more for me than the next 28 days. Our thoughts and prayers (and I'm not a "religious" person so this means a lot) are with you and Ben.
Chris
http://journals.aol.com/swibirun/Inanethoughtsandinsaneramblings
http://journals.aol.com/swibirun/MyJournalJarSaturdaySixetcanswer
No one would think less of you that you have to remove destructive forces from your life (and away from your daughters too!). I too have a sibling I am estranged from, and for far less reasons than you just shared. We are allowed to create our personal world such that it is filled with positive forces. Because someone is "biological family" does not give them special license to abuse us. Sorry for all the pain he put you through.
Peace, Virginia
I have learned that some people you can only love from a distance.... and your brother sounds like one of those.... I am so sorry that this is what you have dealt with. My oldest good brother displays the family dysfunction in alcholism as well, and can be counted on less and less. This is a heartbreaking thing, but I am proud of you for protecting your daughters and yourself.
judi
Sometimes 'Tough Love' is all we can offer.... I know it is hard, but it would be worse if you or your family continued to enable your brother... They say an alcoholic has to hit rock bottom before they can start to climb back up, but I have known a few that just seemed to hit that bottom and lay there instead... {{{{Hugs}}}} I know this is a hard thing, but regardless of how it feels sometimes, you are doing the right thing!
http://journals.aol.com/astaryth/AdventuresofanEclecticMind
Sounds like you've done what you could, put every effort into helping your brother, and sometimes, enough is enough. You have to keep yourself and your kids in a healthy environment, you and your kids have to come first. Even if that means severing the relationship with your brother. Forced to do so, is just how has to be for you to have any sanity and stability in your own life. I'm sorry for your parents, I can't imagine the pain they've been through, nor the pain they continue to feel for your brother, their son.
Your entry hits close to home for me. I was a version of your brother. Thankfully my days of drinking ended for good in August of 1988. The path of destruction I tore through my family nearly distroyed everything I hold dear to my heart. I wrecked cars, physically hurt people, spend thousands of dollars on detox and rehab, drinking through my pregnancy with my daughter, emotionally scarring my 2 sons, my family. Like your brother when I was dry I was an awesome person, but drunk I was a mean, nasty liar. 2 years of my drinking I went to AA. On the August evening I finally shut up and listened. I had a moment where everything was clear. Thankfully I was able to hang on to that moment of clarity where my alcohol obsession finally was removed. And for me I believe for good. Alcohol is not an option for me. the funny thing about alcoholism is that you can watch a person destroy their lives themselves and be an alcoholic yourself and simply not think it applies to you. My brother watched me, and he's a drunk. My children watched me and they over do. I married a man that himself had a problem but on our first date I gave him a choice I simply said this, " I can't tell you what to do but I have no room in my life for alcohol." He was ready to quit and did, without the aid of AA, which I had to have in my first 6 years of sobriety. HIs kids drink too much too. The disease is the only one that says you don't have it. It lies to you , I know in my heart that I will never drink again. But with all things in my life I try to live only in today...and as they teach you in AA you only have to concern yourself with this day, this 24 hours. You needed to get this out your brother is you blood and I know that it is so hard to watch a person you love continue to hurt themselves. I know for me that prayer works, it worked for me. My prayers are with and your brother
I think (and please please don't take offense) that this is the first entry that I've read where you have really dug deep and wrote specifics about. It takes a lot of trust and courage to put yourself out there and not generalize things that have happened. I'm very sorry for your brother. Perhaps one day, he will wake up and realize what a great family, a great sister, he has.
Ari
P.S. I do love your journal, you know.
You showed much courage in being there for your brother as much as you were. Your parents also, must have endured such heartache over this. The picture looks so sweet and seeing you both as young innocents, it saddens me that your brother chose alcohol over family. I guess that's the disease. My family is no stranger to this - which is why we have never had alcohol in the house. I have no desire to let this sickness into my home. One drink a couple times a year for special occasions is ok with me. I did more drinking and partying as a teen than I care to admit, but like you, it was the 2+ years of rebellion and I came out the other side without too many bruises. I hope someday your brother comes around. He has the love of his family, that's for sure.
sorry to hear about your brother sometimes you just can't help loving someone no matter what they did wrong someday that person will have to realize what they did wrong and how much they are hurting the ones who care about them.
~Kristina
sorry to hear about your brother sometimes you just can't help loving someone no matter what they did wrong someday that person will have to realize what they did wrong and how much they are hurting the ones who care about them.
~Kristina
Hey there, first I want to thank you for all of your positive feedback. When I started writing in it, I told myself I wanted to be very candid and for that reason was really nervous about it! But it made me feel really good to know someone out there knows where I'm coming from.
Also, I just read your entry above, and I'm so sorry for you. Unfortunately it is something I'm all too familiar with. My grandfather, father, and 2 uncles (all on my father's side) were/are alcoholics. My father was a jovial drunk - always very happy, funny when we were out. It was when we came home that he was depressed and angry. I really have to respect my Mother for all of her strength during the 14 years they were married, though I think she and us kids would have been better off if she had not stuck it out. When I got older I pretty much cut my father out of my life. It was hard to do that, but even when not drinking, he was so negative that it just wasn't a good complement for my own depression. I felt very sorry for him in his last days. He had alienated almost everyone in our family and still had excuse after excuse for why it was THEIR fault and not his. He had been in out of rehab, had numerous health problems, but nothing could come between he and his liquor. In the end, it was just very sad.
I hope that your brother eventually pulls out of this and rejoins your family. I didn't really get it until I was in my mid twenties but family really is the most important thing we have here and it would be a shame for him to miss out on you and your family. I'm going to hold you all in my prayers tonight and send warm wishes your way. You're a lovely person!
I believe people understand more than you would ever realize. Although you gave me a whole new perspective on it, such as the grief and strength it takes to walk away. Perhaps, I may have to explore my own story in my journal, as I am the who is taking steps to walk away from it all. I wonder if there is an easier path for any of us to follow?
Lioneyes4you
Queen of dDd
http://journals.aol.com/lioneyes4you/DramaDilemmasandDreams
My husband has two aunts and they fit that description of your brother completely! my thoughts are with you
Kelly
Wow, definitely a tough choice...but a wise one. I really admire your courage in letting go of something you couldn't change and couldn't let drag you down.
xoxo~Bernadette
that`s such a sad story, and an all too common one, i definitely have used drinking as a crutch in the past, and therefore by the grace of God could have ended up the same way.......you did the right thing by backing out of his circle, sometimes letting go is the best thing you can do for the other person and definitely for yourself as well.....it doesn`t mean you don`t care or love them, it in fact means you love them so much you`re choosing not to watch them destroy themselves or enable their behavior......thank you for such an open and honest entry....i`m sure it wasn`t esay
Thank you for sharing this-I am trying to play catch up-it gets away from me though-I completely understand your position-but I am also on the other side of it now. My Mom did have recovery for several years before she died and a blessing it was. It is such a disease, it is difficult to feel sympathy for self induced sickness but is an illness just the same. Sounds like some mentall illness as well-my heart goes out to you Rebecca-I understand...and then some!
Had computer difficulties and wanted to say this sooner:
Rebecca:
Thank you for sharing so much in this entry. You have had a very tough time, and have clearly done all you can.
I was struck by the mention of your brother's learning disabilities. It is tragic how many individuals lead troubled lives because they have such problems. I would refer anyone who is interested to the WhyTry Organization (http://www.whytry.org/), which is dedicated to helping and understanding such issues. I was lucky enough to hear the founder speak at a conference recently. He was a dynamic and moving speaker. One story he told was of addressing around 400 convicts at a state prison. He asked how many had been told they had learning disabilities at school. Every hand went up.
We don't do enough to to help these kids in the schools - and so many of them go on to lead difficult and sometimes lawless lives.
Rebecca, I'm not saying that your family didn't do enough - because it sounds like you all did everything you knew how to, and more besides - but there is so much more that we can do as a society - and we are not recognizing it.
OK, I'll step off my soap box - thanks again for sharing this,
Vicky
First...Thanks for the kind words regarding my journal. Being acknowledged for my loving relationship with my twin sister, Julie, something that comes naturally to me seems kind of odd. I forget that not every sibling relationship isn't quite like ours.
Second...I've been avoiding this journal entry because of the incredibly powerful sadness it brings to me. Sadness because alcohol abuse is too common a coping device these days to anesthetize something larger than ourselves. Co-conspirators with alcohol abuse is all its relatives: drug, sexual, physical, emotional, etc., and unfortunately they are all destroyers of good people and good families. Everything that you and your family have done for Benjamin over the years is a testament to your love for him. I hope he sees your love through all his turmoil. Sometimes tough love is the hardest love to give, but the best kind of love for a person to receive.
Third...like my twin sister, Julie, says, "You can't pick your family, but you can pick your friends." I, too, am estranged from family members because of their choices and abusive behaviors. I refuse to tolerate or enable their dysfunction; they know where to find me when they decide to change. It's not easy, Rebecca, but it must be done for your own health and well-being, and for that of your daughters'!
Best,
Judith
http://journals.aol.com/jtuwliens/MirrorMirrorontheWall
What a heart wrenching story. I think all families suffer from dysfunctional relationships over time, but unfortunately, some families experience more than their share. I have a son whose name is Benjamin (nicknamed Ben-Jammin) and it would break my heart if his life revolved around substance abuse. He is the apple of my eye and I am a lucky man to have such a fine son.
But like many, my family also had a substance abuser. My grandmother was an alcoholic and I remember well the embarrassment she caused our family whenever we gathered as a group. She was an only child and many would consider her childhood privileged; private schools, summers at the beach, winters spent in Florida, but somewhere along the way she fell victim to a bottle and became an obnoxious drunk. As a youngster, I couldn't understand her "ailment" and as an adult, just reluctantly accepted her condition.
Sometimes all you can do is let go and its never easy.
Take care,
Rick
I, too, have a brother that suffers from alcoholism...the difference is that God has helped him stay sober for over sixteen years. My brothers addiction began when he was eight years old...our Dad's sense of humor was bent to say the least. For many years the tumultous relationship was everything I dispised and he was everything I loathed. How blessed I trully am now. Mom would have never betted on this happening. WOW! how far we have come. My brother is my best friend and I love him through thick and thin, good and bad, and whatever "hell" we went through was what cemented what we have today! I love you Sandy and thanks for being my brother!
Thanks for sharing that, good for you that you are able to vent and get it out on "paper", even if it was written in a private journal! I envy you being able to get it out as when I'm asked about my brothers, how can I put this, well the oldest one walked out after his 5th( yes, brothers and sisters, I wrote 5TH!) divorce and we don't know if he's dead or alive. The other brother is incommunicado with the family which is just the way we like it as he abused me when I was little. All this makes me a firm believer in the concept a family isn't just who you're born into, but family is who you choose.
Cat
I am one of the lucky ones, I have a brother and a sister I get along with very well. They both have issues that drive me to the edge sometimes, but mostly we are thick with love.
But my ex-husband (Dan) was different, his brothers and sister were all very messed up. The oldest was so much like the story you tell of your brother that I had to read it couple of times to make sure you weren't telling Dan's story. He's an alcolholic and bi-polar and has been in and out of the mental hospital too many times to count.
Dan's parents also had to put a dead bolt on their door, unfortunately when Dan's sister came threatening their lives when she was drunk, she didn't call the police first. She just stabbed her father in the chest, and luckily enough I was here to help pin her down until the ambulance and police came. It was traumatic.
Dan doesn't have anything to do with them, and having been a part of his life I understand. Sometimes you have to walk away from people who can't keep their lives straight .... or you won't have much of a life of your own. You and your parents are in my prayers. I know it's hard for them, and hard for you, even on the outside. The photo was sweet, and the story very honest. Thanks so much for sharing.
~Dawn
http://journals.aol.com/auburndawn/littlepassions
Post a Comment