I've resisted the overt desire to change the last sentence in my previous entry because of fear it somehow begged for compliments. When it was just a sentence to a long vent. Or maybe that should read, delete an entire paragraph. Or possibly I just feel overwhelmed by the comments left. Because just as a comfort level of no longer dismissing my personal thoughts settles in, the age old unease of acceptance of praise, over comes my within.
I've taken the time to explore enough female makeup to understand that we, on a general dimension, find it easier to accept the negative. We take it, package it up, and place it in that room inside us, as an arsenal of defense when faced with accepting a positive. Praise of my writing here on my journal, has brought smiles to my face, confirmation in my mind, and kicked open the doors of the arsenal of weapons.
Impressionable. That was me. I have no formal writing experience, never had a forum of opinion to discuss my writing except once. However significant or insignificant this time was, it made an impression. Even writing this I can see where it may fall, but for the moment I must.
Creative writing class in High School. One of my most impressionable times in my life. I thought, with exhilaration, this would be a place for me. But I was meet with a teacher who had guidelines, who had a formula, that did not fall into my writing style I guess. I consistently received a meager B in his class. For basically a straight A student who loved nothing more then writing, this was perplexing, frustrating and discouraging.
At time's I would receive an A for content, and a F for grammar, spelling, punctuation. <This was a time computers were never used> eking out a mere B if I was lucky. At time's I would receive an F for writing content, he would say, "You strayed way to far away from the guidelines." I would sit in his class and hear the praise of another writer he adored and listen to him read their paper that I thought was stoic, rehearsed and uninteresting. Honestly, I thought I must be whacko, for my writing did not fit his world, but he was the writing teacher! I had thought it was creative writing, but it wasn't. I fought back, I really did, but ultimately he won, him and his guidelines, I transferred out, and protectedmy writing in privacy.
So since then, this has been my first public display of the written word, my journal. So when I read compliments I find myself stricken with his words, his opinion. And I know of course he was just one person, and I'm really trying to kick that door closed again. I thank all for your opinions, came to cherish them actually. A bandaide of sorts for the damage done once to someone so impressionable. So this is my first attempt to overcome those fears and accept without internal revolt your opinions.
Picture this, your someone that has always had no more then 10 bucks in your pocket, and someone hands you a million dollars.......overwhelmed is a good description right? Thankful, appreciative, awe struck, but overwhelmed. And that my dear friends is how I feel.
Like the beautiful and talented Jazz would say...........
Thank you from where it counts!!!

9 comments:
You're right, he's just one person with just one opinion. Had you had a different teacher, that teacher may have praised everything you wrote. I find it similar to the writing tests our state requires our children to take. They are graded by different people. One test scorer may grade more harshly then the next. I didn't take the last sentence as begging for compliments.
Do not allow this obviously bitter unrealized person, who managed to get a teaching degree, and let me just say some people are in the wrong profession, hang around in your brain and have any power over you by believing anything he had to say about you or your creativity.
Remember the female comic, Judy Tenuta's famous line.."you will not POSSESS me!"
So he knows sentence structure? The perfectly written sentence does not a writer make...Sentence structure is good, but has little to do with writing ability or creative energy....Dalene of AHH at http://journals.aol.com/ahhliving/AHH
Rebecca, P.S.! I almost forgot ... is this the sentence you are referring to?
"Wicked world and mercy streets. I may not be heard. But I can write. I can write the most beautiful, melancholy, vivaciously happy things and not apologize. I can express anything my center speaks and when I close my eye's, I am at the center of my imagination."
Because if it is, I thought it rocked. In fact, when I read it, I thought, oh, I would have liked to have written that sentence. Why? Because it rocks! It reminds me of a very good first sentence to the beginning of a very good novel.....Dalene of AHH at http://journals.aol.com/ahhliving/AHH
You do not have to beg for compliments, they are freely given by adults who are of sound mind and body. I am a closet writer because of the same reason. I too, was burned by an English teacher once. Because of that, I had the preconcieved notion that ALL English majors were jerks till I met a beautiful person who defied my stereotype. I am slowly emerging from the writing closet. I am almost there, I can see the light through the crack. I believe writing should not be graded but admired. It is an art, not a science. It is not measurable in numbers because it is conceptual, not formulaic. Writing is an art and one can not be objective about it. And I love your entries that is why I keep coming back for more!
Rebecca,
I know exactly how you feel about the teacher's comments. I addressed the ame issue in a recent posting, because a remembered insult from nearly 40 years ago still lingered and I wanted to exorcise it. I've had many teachers over the years, but that ONE misguided person left me feeling inadequate to do what I wanted so much to do and felt I had a talent for. Perhaps Ian Anderson summed it up best, “did you hear mother, sayin’ I’m wrong, but I know I’m right, did you hear father, calling my name into the night, saying I’ll never be what I am now, telling me I’ll never find what Another guy put it quite well, I've always thought, tho I may be taking this out of context, "To thine ownself be true". And one last comment, from Procol Harum's 2nd album, "Shine On, Brightly". Nuff said, Bruce
Your teacher's comments left their mark, but it's up to you whether it will be a good one or a bad one. You could let that criticism stop you. You could let it make you critical of yourself. Or you can refuse to believe it and use it as fuel for your writing. Use it to prove that teacher wrong and become the best writer you can be.
I think that when you remember your teacher's criticisms, you should also remember that no one ever grew up wanting to be a critic.
"In those moments of exterior silence I hear the mystical sounds of piano notes, flowing, moving me across the keyboard. If I could just compose my life's music across these keys I could rival with the best"
Rebecca - who cares about grammar, spelling, and punctuation when you can write those sentences? Before I read your self-doubt, I thoutht to myself how beautifully Rebecca has expressed herself here. It is gems such as these that show the truly creative person. Machines and prosaic dullards can correct the grammar, spelling, and punctuation. Machines and prosaic dullards cannot create.
You ARE creating your life's music. Keep playing, my dear, loudly enough to drown out the stuffy old creative writing teacher.
Vicky
My Incentive http://www.livejournal.com/~vxv789/
Hi Rebecca!
Thank you for visiting my journal. (Loretta's Salon)
You express yourself quite well.
Actually your express yourself VERY well.
I did study writing... in grad school... so hopefully that will help you see that your teachers' grades did not reflect your ability to create a writing voice.
Not everyone is able to create their own voice in writing.
Here's a little anecdote for you:
Some very famous writers were horrendous at grammar, spelling... all that technical stuff... yet, they get published.
That is what an editor is for.
You know of Charles Dickens?
I believe he was one of those "sloppy" writers.
Any good reader can see the truth in good writing... doesn't matter if there are grammatical errors, colloquial speech, sloppy handwriting...whatever...if you write from the soul... your work will always be authentic and from the soul.
Just keep on doing what you do.
And don't worry about needing validation...
We all need to be validated.
:)
Have a GREAT day!
Loretta
Just listen to all that is said and sit with it. You are filled with grace and gifted in your own right. Sit in the gentle power of that. judi
Post a Comment